We, as gamers, have a lot of franchises that we
praise. In every genre, on every platform. I have always been a Nintendo guy,
so I have their franchises in mind. Other folks grew up with PlayStation or XBox, with their own franchises and exclusives. Others just go PC all the way. We all
agree on one thing, though: Most film adaptations of games suck.
It’s practically proven. If a film is an adaptation of
a famous franchise, it’s most likely going to be terrible. There's more
than a few reasons for that:
-The studio snatched up the rights before it could
form a competent team that knew the subject matter;
-The producers and directors
didn’t seek out info on the adapted franchise;
-The screenwriters did not do the
bloody research and got basic facts wrong;
-The folks in Hollywood associated
with the project aren’t gamers to start with (less likely nowadays, but still
possible);
-The fans know the source material better and can point out every inconsistency between the film and the games;
-Or all of the above with a double dose of incompetence thrown in.
Making a movie about video games without it being an
adaptation isn’t a guarantee that the film will turn out any better, either;
Sure, Wreck-It Ralph was awesome, but Pixels sucked. I can confirm, I saw it
again lately. Blergh. However, there will always be diamonds in the rough, and
a sufficiently talented team could come up with something, maybe not a
masterpiece, but a movie that gamers aren’t ashamed to watch. Today, I fully
acknowledge that these cases are rare and the examples given here are very
unlikely to happen – but a guy can dream. I’m not saying these movies will
happen, or that they won’t ever happen – those are the ramblings of a guy who
likes video games, who likes movies, and would like to see some video game
movies done right. And those are just ideas.
1. Super Mario Bros.
Type: Animated
Nintendo loves its silent player characters. Mario
speaks phrases here or there, but is rarely saying actual, long lines of
dialogue. Yet, we know that Charles Martinet is able to talk for a while as any
of the characters he voices for the franchise, and he has repeatedly shown his
talent for voice acting outside of the Mario franchise. Have you seen those
videos from past conventions where Mario and Luigi were holding actual
Q&As?
A good Mario movie would be quite an achievement.
First, go animated. We're not making the mistake of live-action once again. Second, we
need to have all the characters behave as they do in the series. True, the
setting changes every so often, but the main characters’ personalities are
usually the same regardless of the game. Third, think up a story that would be
doable in movie form, that means a plot resolved in anywhere between 80 minutes
and 2 hours. My best guess? Have Masahiro Sakurai as a creative consultant… and
if that’s impossible, have the next best person with a well of knowledge in the
Mario series that Nintendo can afford to give as a consultant. My other guesses
would be to avoid including new characters that exist solely in the movie,
although that would be difficult. And of course, it would be a shame to make a
movie about this massive franchise without referencing its 35 years of
existence. I have no idea what the plot would be. I know it would include
Mario, Bowser, Luigi, Peach and the Toads, at the very least. It would be a
perfect time to adapt bits and pieces of gameplay of previous titles in the
series. As for the plot? I can think of things I’d love to see, but very few
that would fit together in a single plot. My only wish would be that the end
result turns out good.